Listen On:

organic marketing for coaches

Listen On:

The Power of Organic Marketing: Real Growth for Coaches with Kari Tumminia

Welcome to another inspiring episode of The Abundant Coach! This week, Lauren Brollier Newton dives deep into the world of organic marketing with Kari Tumminia, an expert content creator, coach, and senior marketing manager of brand & organic growth at Brave Thinking Institute. Kari’s insights come from years of experience building her own organic following of over 100,000 people and helping countless coaches create thriving businesses.

During this conversation, Lauren and Kari unpack the fundamentals of organic marketing, showing how it can help coaches build long-term success by fostering authentic connections with their audience. They also tackle the common challenges coaches face, like imposter syndrome and choosing the right marketing platform. If you’ve ever felt overwhelmed by the idea of marketing or unsure how to attract the right clients, this episode will equip you with practical tools, inspiring stories, and the confidence to make organic marketing work for you.

Why Organic Marketing is the Future of Coaching

Organic marketing is a powerful strategy for life coaches who want to build a business rooted in authenticity and trust. Kari explains that organic marketing focuses on providing free value, building relationships, and establishing brand authority, rather than relying on quick sales or paid ads. The result? Loyal clients who are deeply invested in your work.

Unlike direct-response marketing, organic marketing takes time but pays off in big ways by creating raving fans who trust your expertise. These are the clients who return again and again and recommend you to others.

What Organic Marketing Includes

Organic marketing encompasses a wide variety of activities, many of which cost nothing but your time and creativity. Some key examples are:

  • Social media content (Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook)
  • Blogging or writing articles that solve your audience’s problems
  • Creating video content or podcasts
  • Hosting free workshops or attending networking events

The goal is to show up authentically, provide value, and connect with your ideal clients before making a sale.

Where to Start: The Two Key Questions for Coaches

If you’re new to organic marketing or feel overwhelmed, start with these two questions:

  1. Where are your ideal clients spending their time?
    • Think about whether they are active on Instagram, searching for blogs on Google, or attending in-person workshops.
  2. What do you love doing the most?
    • Choose a marketing method that feels natural and enjoyable for you, whether that’s writing, creating videos, or connecting with people in person.

By answering these questions, you can focus your efforts on the platforms and strategies that will have the biggest impact while staying aligned with your strengths and passions.

Overcoming Imposter Syndrome to Market Authentically

Imposter syndrome is one of the biggest challenges many coaches face, especially when starting out. Kari shares practical advice for reframing these feelings:

  • Understand that imposter syndrome is not an identity—it’s a skill gap that you can overcome with time and practice.
  • Identify whether you’re more afraid of losing relationships (what close friends or family might think) or damaging your reputation (what strangers might think). Address those fears directly.
  • Remember that even negative feedback or disagreement can be helpful. As Kari says, “Controversy is a strategy.” Use it to deepen your message and attract the people who truly resonate with your work.

The key to overcoming imposter syndrome is to keep showing up. Authenticity is your most powerful tool as a coach, and being vulnerable and real will attract the right clients to you.

Why Organic Clients Are the Best Clients

Kari and Lauren highlight a major benefit of organic marketing: clients who come to you organically are often your most loyal and engaged clients. These clients have already built a relationship with you through your content, so by the time they decide to work with you, they’re deeply invested in your mission.

Organic clients tend to:

  • Stay with you longer
  • Engage more fully in your programs
  • Be more likely to refer you to others

Building trust and authority through organic marketing creates lifelong fans who see your value and are excited to work with you.

The Role of Authenticity in Organic Marketing

The era of perfectly polished content is over. Today’s audiences are drawn to real, relatable people. Kari shares a powerful story of how her first viral TikTok video was completely unpolished—she had no makeup on and was sitting on her couch late at night—but it resonated deeply with viewers, gaining over 500,000 views and 20,000 followers in just 12 hours.

The lesson? You don’t need perfection to succeed in organic marketing. You just need to show up as yourself.

Key Takeaways

  1. Organic marketing is a long-term strategy that builds trust, authenticity, and client loyalty.
  2. Start by identifying where your clients are and what type of content you enjoy creating.
  3. Overcome imposter syndrome by reframing it as a skill gap and focusing on your purpose rather than external validation.
  4. Authentic, imperfect content is often the most effective—it connects with people on a human level.
  5. Clients who find you through organic marketing are more likely to become lifelong fans and advocates for your work.

Are you ready to finally turn your passion for helping others into a thriving coaching business? 

Whether you’re just starting out or feeling stuck, the Life Coach Accelerator will give you the clarity, tools, and confidence to make your dream a reality. 

In this free, 5-day challenge, you’ll learn how to:

  • Clarify your purpose and identify the clients you’re meant to serve
  • Build a sustainable business model that aligns with your passion
  • Overcome common blocks like money fears and self-doubt
  • Find your ideal clients and confidently charge what you’re worth

This is your chance to take actionable steps toward creating the coaching business—and life—you’ve always dreamed of. Sign up now for free!

MK-CC-Blog-CTA-LCA-5DC-Banner-Footer in-text